There is no "in-between"

Life in our world has many sorts of enmity.  Enmities between a husband and wife on the brink of divorce, bullies and their victims, a person betrayed by a friend, or a child abused by a parent.  Enmities between nations at war or adversaries in civil war.  Between cheaters and cheated, criminals and victims.  Among the wealthy and among the poor, and between rich and poor.  Enmities between “maskers” and “non-maskers”, “vaxxers” and “anti-vaxxers”.  Between Democrats and Republicans.  Whatever the sort, only two options occur to me as possible for those embroiled in enmity; either let it be or deal with it.  There really isn't any "in between."

Letting an enmity be will likely make it worse.  Recrimination will increase.  Old hurts will get bruised and new ones will be perpetrated.  Grudges and resentments will fester.  Violence and bloodshed may even happen.  And all this will occur for the enemies on both sides of a divide.

Dealing with the enmity requires both parties to turn their faces to one another and listen.  Each needs to acknowledge to the other their own responsibility for the division, and to forgive the hurt and misunderstanding the other has caused—more or less in that order.   When all this takes root—on both sides –genuine reconciliation, which consists of deep-down mutual forgiveness, becomes a real possibility.   But sometimes it will occur only with the grace of God.  If that’s the case, then both sides will benefit from praying for the grace to reconcile.

For reconciliation to stick, the process needs to grow towards mutual love.  This is more than mutual tolerance or respect.  Love, in a situation where reconciliation has begun and is maturing will consist of not just words but especially in deeds:  public acknowledgement of the dignity and goodness of the other (praise), revering the other in their dignity and goodness, and supporting the other by helping them to heal, reconstruct damaged relationships, and otherwise serving them.

To come to a point of praising, revering, and serving an enemy one needs to experience the mutual forgiveness and healing which reconciliation makes possible.  Then, as reconciliation flourishes, union of hearts and minds becomes a desired goal to work for, and the love that results will abide.  When union and love are achieved, they become the doorway to peace, deep and enduring peace -- which is the polar opposite of enmity.

I think heeding the words of Christ from Matthew’s gospel strikes at the root of enmity:  "You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.  But I say to you, love your enemies, and pray for those who persecute you, that you may be children of your heavenly Father, for he makes his sun rise on the bad and the good, and causes rain to fall on the just and the unjust" (Matthew 5:43-48).

This is the love that God wants to give grace for when we’re experiencing enmity, the same love Our Lord gave words to from the cross: "Father, forgive them, they do not know what they are doing" (Luke 23:34).